In my last installment , I showed that Bank Of
America (NYSE: BAC) preferred trusts are trading at yields that are
completely arbitrary when compared to their own nearly identical
trusts. I further pointed out that the Merrill Lynch Trusts,
which are basically the same trusts with the exact same terms,
trade at an even greater discrepancy.
Let's get into further details. The below chart shows the
ticker, the annual dividend, the Friday closing price, the
resulting yield and the resulting "strip yield." Strip yield
is just a more accurate yield for comparison purposes, taking into
account accrued dividends based on each dividend's payout
settlement date.
They have different tickers, different dividend payout dates, and
in the case of Merrill, a different name. But they are all
basically the same intertwined combined company and each prospectus
is nearly identical. All of these are senior to the
government's debt which makes them especially attractive.
But what I am focusing your attention on is the dramatic difference
in yields based on current closing prices, in order to show just
how amazingly inefficient the current market really is:
TICKER DIV PRICE YIELD
DATE/DAYS STRIP YIELD
MER-K 1.613 7.05
22.88% 12/15 (71) 23.95%
MER-M 1.613 6.85 23.55%
12/15 (71) 24.66%
MER-D 1.75 6.50
26.92% 12/30 (56) 28.09%
MER-E 1.78 6.72
26.49% 12/30 (56) 27.63%
MER-F 1.82 6.93
26.26% 12/30 (56) 27.37%
MER-P 1.844 7.80 23.64%
12/15 (71) 24.78%
BAC-U 1.469 9.50 15.58%
02/02 (22) 15.61%
BAC-Y 1.5 8.51
17.86% 02/05 (19) 17.80%
BAC-Z 1.5 8.70
17.47% 02/25 (00) 17.47%
BAC-B 1.563 8.58 18.18%
12/30 (56) 18.74%
BAC-C 1.719 8.65 19.88%
02/02 (22) 20.11%
BAC-V 1.75 9.50
18.53% 02/02 (22) 18.63%
BAC-W 1.75 9.00
19.56% 12/15 (71) 20.21%
Notice first of all the most obvious discrepancy, BAC-C and
BAC-V. They have the exact same settlement date, the exact
same name, but their yields are about 150 basis points apart.
Then, notice BAC-U vs. BAC-W. 460 basis points apart!
Again, it even has the same name.
But the real shocker is how apart Merrill's Capital Trusts are when
there is no possible scenario anybody can reasonably come up with
where these trusts should be considered different than Bank of
America trusts at this point. In fact, analysts David Spring
and Sharon Haas of Fitch recently downgraded all of the
trusts altogether with the same rating and analysts have been
consistently doing so, because of course, they are essentially the
same. Yet, look at the strip yield of MER-D versus
BAC-U. That's a 12.48% difference, or put it another way - an
80% spread! The Merrills trade at an enormous discount to the
BAC's. The spread ought to be inconsequential. Instead,
it is enormous and presents yet another special opportunity in this
wildly inefficient market we find ourselves in.
In buying Bank of America prefferreds (which includes Merrill,
Countrywide, etc.), do yourself a favor and go for the best
yield. There is absolutely no reason someone should be buying
BAC-U at that closing price over any of those other trusts.
That is not an opinion, in this case. It is a mathematical
fact.