Super Bullish, glad to see support for the deal.
A snippet from their report:
Deal synergy deep dive – €900m target too
conservative
In this note we analyse potential revenue synergies,
dis-synergies and cost savings
opportunities from the announced Alcatel acquisition. Based on
our analysis, we
conclude that Nokia may eventually be able to deliver up to
twice its current synergy
target. We estimate cost savings could be >€2bn mostly
in wireless R&D, Opex
efficiencies from regional overlap and COGS savings from larger
procurement scale
and manufacturing. We estimate €0.3bn in revenue synergies
and c. €0.6bn in dissynergies,
driving potential NET synergies of €1.8bn. These would be
worth c.
€3.2/share and with the stock in our view only discounting
pro forma net cash and
PRE Synergy Networks margins currently, we continue to see an
attractive ‘deep
value’/risk reward opportunity. We maintain our 12-month
€9.3 PO, and also our
base case scenario for the deal, in which Nokia delivers its
synergy target, implying
a theoretical fair value of €11.5 in 2018, discounted back.
BUY.
Achieving twice the synergies could give significant
upside
According to our scenario analysis (see inside), if Nokia is
able to deliver twice its
synergy target ie €1.8bn, generating €0.83 in 2019E
EPS power for the combined
entity, we estimate a valuation of €14 in 2018.
Deal synergies & IPR not in the price
Based on our SOTP analysis we believe the current share price is
only discounting
net cash (€1.9/share assuming HERE disposal for
€2.5bn) and pre-synergy
Networks margins (8.5% margins/0.85x sales= €4.1/share). It
appears that the
market has no value ascribed to deal synergies (base case
€1.5/share, bull case
€3.2/share) and IPR/Technologies. We view the current share
price as a ‘deep
value’/risk reward opportunity.