THQ announced today that they made .09 non-GAAP earnings from
what looked to be a spectacular quarter, which included UFC
Undisputed, Red Faction and considerable cost reductions. Now
they are talking about making only around 90 million in revenues in
the second quarter and somewhere in the ballpark of -.50
earnings. That'll make it around -.41 first half, relying on
Darksiders and a good holiday for the second half.
Should anybody really hang their hat on Darksiders? On
today's conference call, CEO Brian Farrell suggested that they
should, talking about it at great length.
As a part of their guidance, THQ also talked as they did in the
previous quarter about having 50 million more cash than the end of
the last fiscal year, or 190 million in cash. Another
simultaneous press release revealed that 90 million of that will be
from senior convertible debt they are issuing.
Surprise.
That will result in around 100 million cash minus debt (considering
a 33 million payment to JAKKS Pacific, Inc.), or around 15% future
dilution - take your pick. So you have a company gunning for
100 million cash minus debt next year with such hit titles as
Darksiders and MX Racing and instead of 'targeting' profitability
now they are guiding for it. That's just great.
Now, assuming they meet expectations this year, where is future
year growth coming from? Farrell says they will try to
release two new "core titles" every year. One example of that
will apparently be Red Faction 2 which was discussed on the call
(while the current one is only two months into its release and
likely not even profitable at this time). They're also
working on another UFC game for next year as if it is a perfect
candidate to be an annual franchise (while EA and others limit
similar fighting games to once every other year). Is the next
immediate installment of UFC going to match this year's demand,
when there may have been years of pent up demand for the current
offering? We shall see.
The truth about this company as I see it is the CEO has decided
to take limited risks, which means limited growth potential for the
company. Why? Because he wants to keep his job.
THQ will therefore survive as a company but I do not believe there
is hope of a major new hit right around the corner. The true
value of a video game publisher is their earnings, their management
and their internal intellectual property. THQ has the most limited
number of non licensed intellectual property of any major publisher
and has a management that has 'managed' to drop the value of its
shares by over 80%.
Analysts expect .11 profit this year and .29 profit next
year. Considering the company's limited amount of internal
intellectual property and dependency on partners, the company
should receive a lower earnings multiple from investors than its
peers. By any measure, that figure would be less than its
current trading price above $8.
Disclosure: shorting THQI