Lending a Helping
Hand
Record debt auctions by the Treasury last week totaled
$260 billion ($109 billion in Notes - not including the replacement
of maturing securities in the Fed portfolio), including weak
offerings of 2-year and 5-year Treasury Notes on Tuesday and
Wednesday respectively [Related: ProShares UltraShort 20+ Year Year
Treasury ProShares (NYSE: TBT]. Indirect bids (some of which have
traditionally been foreign official institutions) were unimpressive
and fears began to circulate that the market was already saturated.
Thus the surprise of many when the 7-year $28 billion auction on
Thursday went well with plenty of participation by indirect
bidders. While questions still remain concerning the recent
reclassification of bidders that comprise the indirect category,
there is still the surprise of healthy demand for these longer
dated issues and this is addressed below. On a related note, while
foreign official institutions have been increasing their treasury
purchases, I am skeptical that the buying was from these
institutions as foreign purchasers (playing it more conservative
w/respect to US debt) have been net sellers on the long end.
Federal Reserve custodial holdings of treasuries surpassed the $2
trillion mark last week. However, much of this is due to foreign
institutions selling their 1) Longer dated treasury debt and 2)
Agency debt and MBSs, replacing these holdings with shorter term
treasuries.
It is important for the longer dated auctions to provide the
perception of success. Investors (especially foreign official
institutions) are watching the results of these longer dated
auctions closely. Continued weakness will place even more pressure
on the Treasury and Federal Reserve. While the Federal Reserve has
no authority to lend directly to the Treasury, it has certainly
been providing indirect support. Since March 25th (commencement of
the Treasury purchase program by the Fed), the Fed has purchased
$229.207 billion in treasury securities from its primary dealer
network. More importantly, $94 billion of that debt was set
to mature in about seven years or more (some of these
securities were just shy of the 7-year mark ... but still quite
relevant for our purposes). Meanwhile, the Treasury has auctioned
$245 billion of 7-year, 10-year, and 30-year securities since the
Treasury purchase program at the Fed commenced. Thus, the Fed has
essentially supported 38.4% of the longer dated Treasury auctions
during this time period. Is there any wonder that the 7-year
auction last week went well? The Fed has been draining the supply
of these securities in significant proportions on a consistent
basis.
Looking at more recent activity, the Fed executed purchases of
treasury securities totaling $12.99 billion maturing in about seven
years or more. These purchases came on 7/21, 7/23, and 7/29, with
nearly $7 billion on 7/21 coming in the form of treasuries with
maturities of seven to eight years. With the 7-year debt auction on
Thursday 7/30 being $28 billion, the Fed gave the market a nice
head start soaking a substantial supply of longer term debt and
specifically treasuries in the seven year maturity range. What is
also clear is that the primary dealers purchasing the securities at
auction are not holding these securities long before the Fed comes
to the rescue. Let's take the 7-year 3.25% coupon Treasury Notes
auctioned by the Treasury on 6/25/09 as an example. $2.722
billion of this particular issue (CUSIP 912828KZ2) was purchased by
the Fed on the day of issuance (6/30/09), with an additional $3.785
billion a mere three weeks later on 7/21/09. This is not
atypical as there are many examples where the Fed executed large
purchases of securities in close proximity to the actual auction of
those securities . On the Fed calendar this week is the purchase of
some longer dated treasury securities (Wednesday and Thursday),
including some with maturities of seven to ten years. I would
venture to say that a sizeable stake of these securities were
auctioned by the Treasury in the last couple of months, maybe even
last Thursday. It makes you wonder if the Fed is not encouraging
primary dealer participation in these auctions by making it
abundantly clear that the Fed will absorb a sizeable portion of
their inventory quickly, while still assuring dealer profits. This
is about as close as it gets to the Fed lending directly to the
Treasury, without actually doing it. Federal Reserve treasury
security purchases can be found here .... [See link]
What happens when the $300 billion purchase program limit has been
met? At the current rate of purchases, this will be sometime in
early September. Will the Fed extend this program? A few possible
outcomes ...
- The Fed does not extend the program and the Treasury
continues its schedule of longer dated auctions (monthly and in
consistent amounts for the 7-year, 10-year, and 30-year
treasuries). Here, longer dated treasuries will fall and yields
will rise, sans some unexpected reversal of investor sentiment with
respect to these securities. The impact on the economy and
particularly the housing market will be significant.
- The Fed does not extend the program and the Treasury cuts
back on the volume of longer dated auctions, replacing them with
securities of shorter duration. Here, the average maturity of
outstanding Treasury debt will continue to decline, forcing the
Treasury to roll over maturing debt more often. This is also much
riskier for our economy in that investors will have more leverage
over short term interest rates, which will also impact longer term
interest rates over time.
- The Fed extends the program. Regardless of what the Treasury
does, this additional debt monetization will result in more bank
reserves created by the Fed and all other things being equal, an
increased monetary base. Also, at some point, investors will shun
these securities in larger numbers, driving longer term interest
rates higher.
Revelation of the path chosen by the Federal Reserve and
Treasury will not be long in coming.
|
|